In 1877, the United States was in the midst of a profound and often bitter debate over its monetary system, a conflict known as the "Battle of the Standards." The nation operated on a de facto gold standard following the
Specie Payment Resumption Act of 1875, which aimed to restore the convertibility of paper "greenbacks"—issued during the Civil War—into gold by January 1, 1879. This policy, championed by creditors, industrialists, and Eastern financial interests, sought to ensure a "hard," stable currency backed by precious metal, which they believed was essential for long-term investment, international trade, and upholding the credit of the government.
However, this commitment to gold sparked fierce opposition from a coalition of debtors, farmers, and silver miners, particularly in the South and West. They advocated for the expansion of the money supply through the
free and unlimited coinage of silver at a ratio of 16-to-1 against gold, arguing that a "soft" currency would ease the burden of debt, raise agricultural prices, and fuel economic growth. The previous year, their cause had gained significant momentum with the passage of the
Bland-Allison Act (though it was vetoed by President Hayes and later overridden by Congress in early 1878), which mandated limited government purchase and coinage of silver, creating a bimetallic system in name but one still dominated by gold.
The currency debate was not merely economic but deeply political and social, reflecting the regional and class fractures of the post-Reconstruction era. The year 1877 itself was marked by the cataclysmic
Great Railroad Strike, partly fueled by wage cuts during a depression, which highlighted the economic distress felt by many. Against this backdrop of industrial unrest and agrarian protest, the "money question" became a defining issue, pitting the deflationary pressures of the gold standard against the inflationary hopes of the silver movement, a conflict that would dominate American politics until the climactic "Cross of Gold" election of 1896.