In 1729, the Papal States’ currency system was characterized by significant complexity and instability, a legacy of the fragmented political and economic landscape of Italy. The state issued its own silver
scudo and copper
baiocco coins, but these circulated alongside a multitude of foreign currencies, particularly Spanish silver pieces-of-eight and gold coins from other Italian states and beyond. This proliferation of different coins, each with fluctuating intrinsic metal values, created chronic confusion in trade and public finance. The Papal Mint struggled with the technical and administrative challenges of maintaining consistent coinage, leading to occasional debasements and public distrust.
The situation was further strained by the broader European context of the early 18th century, a period marked by frequent wars and metallic currency shortages. Pope Benedict XIII (1724-1730), whose pontificate covered this period, was a pious reformer more focused on theological and disciplinary matters than on intricate economic policy. Consequently, there was no decisive monetary reform during his reign to consolidate or stabilize the currency. The treasury faced persistent deficits, often financed through borrowing and the manipulation of coin values, which only exacerbated the inflationary pressures and speculative practices within the state's economy.
Ultimately, the monetary disarray of 1729 was symptomatic of the Papal States' broader administrative weaknesses during the ancien régime. The lack of a unified, trusted currency hindered commerce and state revenue collection, embedding economic vulnerability. This instability would persist until more concerted, though often still problematic, reforms were attempted later in the century under popes like Clement XII and Benedict XIV, who began to address the standardization of weights, measures, and coinage in a more systematic manner.